The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is pushing back against claims that an ICE agent seen during an arrest operation in Martha’s Vineyard displayed a white supremacist tattoo. The controversy erupted after footage posted online showed the officer bearing a Valknot symbol — a Nordic design often associated with the god Odin.
Photographer Charlie Giordano, who confronted ICE agents and shared the footage on Instagram, claimed the Valknot is “a symbol often used by white supremacy groups.” The Martha’s Vineyard Times was the first to report on the allegations, which quickly gained traction on social media.
In response, DHS spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin issued a forceful denial on X (formerly Twitter), calling the allegations a “smear” against the agent, who she said is a combat veteran. “His tattoo is a tribute to fallen warriors — a pretty common tattoo in the military among combat veterans who embrace the Nordic Viking warrior culture,” McLaughlin wrote. “Pretending his tattoo is meant to be a tribute to White Supremacy is false, pathetic, and insulting to veterans.”
Symbolic Context and Controversy
The Valknot — three interlocking triangles — has historically been linked to Norse mythology and used in contexts honoring fallen warriors. However, the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) notes that some white supremacist groups, particularly racist Odinists, have appropriated the symbol. Still, the ADL cautions that the Valknot’s appearance should be “carefully examined in context,” as many non-racist pagans and veterans also use the symbol.
ICE acknowledged this nuance in a statement to the Martha’s Vineyard Times, saying the agent had the tattoo before joining the agency and that he “is absolutely not connected with white supremacism in any way.”
Wider Cultural Tensions
The tattoo debate echoes a broader cultural divide surrounding historical symbols and their modern interpretations. For instance, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth came under scrutiny for a “Deus Vult” tattoo — Latin for “God Wills It” — a phrase linked to the Crusades and, more recently, appropriated by some far-right groups. Critics called the tattoo a white nationalist dog whistle, while supporters, including Vice President JD Vance, dismissed the backlash as “disgusting anti-Christian bigotry.”
Operational Context
The ICE operation in Martha’s Vineyard, which sparked the initial controversy, resulted in 40 arrests. The island — known for its affluent vacation crowd — also hosts a significant Brazilian immigrant population. The visible presence of federal immigration enforcement on the island has drawn sharp reactions from local residents and civil rights groups.
As symbolism, identity, and law enforcement practices continue to intersect in highly politicized ways, debates like this highlight the difficulty of disentangling personal expression from public perception — especially in a polarized environment.
Related topics: